EB-1A as an engineer: where appeals most often fell short
Engineers often ask which EB-1A criteria are hardest to prove. We looked at 148 contested EB-1A decisions from the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) where the field was engineering. Software engineers were covered in an earlier post, so this one is for engineers outside software.
A note on the data: these decisions skew toward petitions that were denied first. Read these numbers as where contested cases most often fell short, never as approval odds.
## Where contested findings fell short
Share of AAO criterion findings marked "not met" for engineers:
- Original contributions of major significance: 22 of 23
- Awards: 17 of 18
- High salary: 13 of 16
- Scholarly articles: 11 of 15
- Membership: 9 of 9
- Leading or critical role: 8 of 10
- Judging: 8 of 10
These are small samples, so read them as patterns only.
## What to do with each one
- Original contributions. The USCIS Policy Manual says funding, patents or publication alone do not necessarily show major significance. Stronger signs include wide expert commentary, citations high relative to peers, and significant attention or commercialization. Takeaway: show who outside your employer adopted or built on your work.
- Awards. The criterion asks for lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes for excellence. Takeaway: document who gives the award, who competes for it and how the field recognizes it.
- High salary. Officers compare your pay with others in your field, and compensation surveys are useful. A credible offer can also show you command a high salary. Takeaway: use a survey for your exact occupation.
- Membership. The association must require outstanding achievement, judged by recognized experts. Membership based mainly on payment or general eligibility generally does not count, though a fellow tier selected by experts may. Takeaway: show the selection rules, in writing.
- Scholarly articles. This was met most often here, in 4 of 15 findings. Takeaway: if you publish, it can be a solid base criterion.
## Remember the second step
Meeting three criteria is only step one. In the final merits determination, the officer weighs the whole record to decide whether you are among the small percentage at the very top of your field. Plan your evidence for both steps.
Which criterion feels weakest in your file right now?
Check your self-petition fit free, no account needed: https://www.f-1careers.com/explorer?utm_source=community&utm_medium=post&utm_campaign=eb1a_engineering_criteria
Sources: F-1 Careers analysis of USCIS AAO non-precedent decisions (148 EB-1A engineering decisions); USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 (https://www.uscis.gov/policy-manual/volume-6-part-f-chapter-2)
Education and strategy, not legal advice. Talk to a licensed immigration attorney about your situation.
