EB-1A for managers and founders: which criteria fail most?
Business is the largest field in our EB-1A data, the home of roles like managers, founders and consultants. We looked at 752 AAO decisions on EB-1A petitions classified in business to see where the evidence most often fell short.
A note on the data: AAO cases come from petitions USCIS had already denied, so they skew heavily toward denials. The counts below are contested findings where the AAO said a criterion was or was not met. They are not approval odds.
## Where business petitions most often fell short
| Criterion | Met | Not met | Share not met |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lesser awards or prizes | 48 | 327 | 87% |
| Leading or critical role | 73 | 238 | 77% |
| Published material about you | 30 | 226 | 88% |
| Original contributions of major significance | 16 | 222 | 93% |
| Scholarly articles | 28 | 192 | 87% |
| High salary | 28 | 178 | 86% |
| Judging the work of others | 39 | 176 | 82% |
| Membership requiring outstanding achievement | 25 | 163 | 87% |
Takeaway: Original contributions had the lowest share met, and leading role was claimed often but still fell short in most contested findings.
## Original contributions: show the field changed
The USCIS Policy Manual says work that provoked "widespread commentary on its importance from others working in the field" can show major significance. Funding, patents or publication alone will not necessarily establish it.
Takeaway: Show outside adoption of your method or product, with proof from beyond your own company.
## Leading role: performance beats title
The Policy Manual says "It is not the title of the person's role, but rather the person's performance in the role" that matters. A title with matching duties can help.
Takeaway: For each role, document what you owned, the decisions you made, and the measurable results, in letters from the organization.
## Salary and press need context
High salary is judged "relative to the compensation paid to others" in the field. Published material must be about you and your work, and marketing material written to promote your services does not count.
Takeaway: Benchmark pay against people in your role and location, and collect coverage that is about you, in outlets with real readership.
## Three criteria is only step one
After you meet at least three criteria, the officer weighs everything to decide whether you are among "that small percentage who has risen to the very top of the field of endeavor."
Takeaway: Make every exhibit support one story of acclaim at the top of your field.
Which criterion is hardest to prove in your business role? Tell us in the comments.
Check your self-petition fit free, no account needed: https://www.f-1careers.com/explorer?utm_source=community&utm_medium=post&utm_campaign=eb1a_business_criteria
Sources: F-1 Careers analysis of USCIS AAO non-precedent decisions (752 EB-1A decisions in business); USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 (Extraordinary Ability).
Education and strategy, not legal advice. Talk to a licensed immigration attorney about your situation.
