Which EB-1A criteria fail most on appeal: 909 AAO decisions ranked
Picking your three EB-1A criteria is a strategy choice. We ranked all ten criteria using 909 contested USCIS AAO appeal decisions on EB-1A petitions, covering 2,733 findings where the AAO said a criterion was met or not met.
A note on the data: AAO appeals come from petitions that were already denied once, so the sample skews heavily toward denials. The percentages below are the share of contested findings where the AAO found the criterion met. They are not approval odds.
## The ranking
| Criterion | Met | Not met | Share met |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leading or critical role | 86 | 295 | 23% |
| Display at exhibitions (arts) | 27 | 96 | 22% |
| Judging the work of others | 53 | 216 | 20% |
| Scholarly articles | 43 | 247 | 15% |
| High salary | 37 | 232 | 14% |
| Awards or prizes | 59 | 403 | 13% |
| Published material about you | 35 | 272 | 11% |
| Membership requiring outstanding achievement | 27 | 213 | 11% |
| Commercial success (performing arts) | 5 | 52 | 9% |
| Original contributions of major significance | 22 | 313 | 7% |
Takeaway: even the strongest criterion was found met in fewer than 1 in 4 contested findings.
## Original contributions is the hardest
Only 22 of 335 contested findings were met. The USCIS Policy Manual says originality alone is not enough, and that funding, patents or publication alone do not necessarily show major significance. Helpful evidence includes widespread commentary in the field, high citations relative to peers, and patents that drew significant attention or commercialization.
Takeaway: show what changed outside your own team because of your work, with independent proof.
## Awards: claimed most, rarely met
Awards drew the most contested findings (462). The Policy Manual says awards limited to a single locality, employer or school usually carry little national recognition.
Takeaway: for each award, document who competes, how winners are chosen and any national coverage.
## Salary needs a comparison
In our dataset, a salary not compared with others in the field was tagged as the reason in 90 findings. The Policy Manual says pay is compared with others in the field using surveys and similar data, and a credible contract or offer can show you command a high salary.
Takeaway: benchmark your pay against your occupation and location with published data.
## Three criteria is only step one
USCIS uses a two-step review. After the criteria, the officer weighs the full record to decide whether you have sustained national or international acclaim and are "one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor."
Check your self-petition fit free, no account needed: https://www.f-1careers.com/explorer?utm_source=community&utm_medium=post&utm_campaign=eb1a_criteria_ranked
Sources: F-1 Careers analysis of USCIS AAO non-precedent decisions (909 EB-1A decisions, 2,733 criterion findings); USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 (Extraordinary Ability).
Education and strategy, not legal advice. Talk to a licensed immigration attorney about your situation.
